Warm wood tables and bentwood chairs in a welcoming lakeside dining room overlooking a quiet lake and bare November shoreline.

Mayville's Long-Empty Restaurant Buildings Are Serving Food Again

Travis Bensink told Lake Erie Living that "sometimes you'd see 30 snowmobiles in our lot" at Tulip's Brunch House. The lot belongs to 186 S. Erie St., the former House on the Hill. That restaurant last served a meal in 2019.

Three Mayville restaurant buildings that sat closed for years now have food in them again. Each came back a different way. The fourth building, next door to Tulip's, is the largest of the group and the only one with its own dock. This winter the Village is collecting ideas for its next chapter.

The burned-out diner lot on West Chautauqua Street

The Mayville Diner served the village from the same West Chautauqua Street site for more than 70 years, until an arson fire destroyed it on Dec. 9, 2019. The Post-Journal reported that the Village of Mayville then took possession of the property, cleaned it up and sold it.

That sale became the Tim Hortons at 7 W. Chautauqua St. Local and county officials held the ribbon-cutting in January 2026. Gina and David Kron own it, their sixth restaurant after locations in Westfield, Cassadaga, Dunkirk and Fredonia. In the same Post-Journal story, Mayor Rick Syper credited state Sen. George Borrello with introducing him to the Krons. County Executive PJ Wendel said he sees Tim Hortons cups on desks all through the county office building, which is within walking distance. The location page lists Monday dine-in and drive-thru hours of 6 a.m. to 9 p.m.

The Village handled this comeback directly. A public cleanup turned a fire site into a lot someone could build on.

House on the Hill becomes Tulip's

The next one took a private buyer. In February 2025, the OBSERVER reported that Brian and Erin Pender of Northlake Development had bought both the former House on the Hill and the former Watermark on South Erie Street. The purchase also included several parcels, among them a parking lot across the street. The Penders had already turned the abandoned Peacock Freemason Lodge at 114 S. Erie St. into Chautauqua Lake Dental, which opened in August 2023. Brian Pender gave the paper the reason in one line: "There was no reason for these buildings to be vacant."

Pender said the plan was to find operators rather than run the restaurants themselves. "We don't want to be an absentee landlord," he told the OBSERVER. The House on the Hill operator turned out to be Travis and Tawn Bensink. Travis spent nearly 20 years cooking for hotels, restaurants and Chautauqua Institution before opening a place of his own.

Tulip's Brunch House opened at 186 S. Erie St. on June 21, 2025, and held a grand opening that October. When the OBSERVER covered the grand opening, the Bensinks listed hours of 7 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. every day, with breakfast and lunch served the whole time. "If you want a cheeseburger at 7 a.m. or you wants eggs and toast at 2:30 p.m., we do it all day," Tawn said. Travis's picks in the Lake Erie Living profile are the French toast brûlée, which is brioche dipped in pot de crème and seared, and the Brunch Madam, which stacks ham, Swiss, a poached egg, béchamel and hollandaise.

Location is a big part of why the building works year-round. The Bensinks told the OBSERVER that customers come by boat from a nearby public dock in warm months and by snowmobile from the trails in cold ones. After 3:30 p.m. the space is available for private events. For current hours, the Tulip's Facebook page and (716) 224-2888 are the places to check.

The Redline goes back to its drive-in roots

The Redline Drive-In at 5117 W. Lake Road had been dark longer than either of the others. The Post-Journal traced its history back to the early 1960s, when it opened as one of the early Dogs and Suds stands. The Anzalone family bought and renovated it in 2004 and ran it as the Redline for nearly 15 years. They couldn't open for the 2018 season, and the restaurant's social media went quiet after that.

The property sold in July 2025. A new ownership group, Redline LLC, is made up of four locals: Dan Kenzie, Brian Stahlsmith, Marya Johnson and Jessica Gordon. Their announcement promised to restore "the nostalgia as well as the good food," naming every chapter of the stand's history: "From A&W, Dog and Suds, The Feedbag, to Redline." The drive-in was set to open its doors on May 18, 2026. By July 7, the drive-in was on the county's food-service inspection register at its West Lake Road address.

The Watermark, next door and still waiting

That leaves 188 S. Erie St., the former Watermark, which closed in 2022. It sits right beside Tulip's, and it's the largest building in the group. Northlake describes it as 5,500 square feet with a full kitchen, seating, an expansive deck, a concrete patio and direct dock access. The company is pitching it to a restaurant, brewery or event-venue operator.

In 2025, Pender told the OBSERVER that the Watermark "needs a little TLC." He also said that "it's a much bigger space so you've really got to find the right person," and that he expected it could open fairly quickly once that person turns up.

The dock is what makes the Watermark unusual. Boaters can already tie up at the public dock and walk to Tulip's. At the Watermark, the dock belongs to the building.

The same 2025 OBSERVER story laid out a longer goal for the Penders. Brian Pender is president of the Mayville Area Chamber of Commerce and sits on the Mayville-Chautauqua Comprehensive Planning Committee. He said they hoped to build "a large-scale housing project" somewhere in the area, and he described the 1.8-acre lot across from the two restaurants as a possible project. Back then he described it as planning-stage work, with senior housing, workforce housing, apartments and condos all under consideration.

Where residents get a say this winter

The next decisions about this stretch of the village have a public side. The Village of Mayville is preparing an application to New York State's NY Forward program, which funds downtown projects such as public spaces, infrastructure, business growth and housing. In its October newsletter, the Village asked residents, business owners, property owners and community groups to send in project ideas on a Project Interest Form, and it invited the public to an Oct. 7 meeting on the application. Details are on the Village's NY Forward page.

The Village also has an online community survey open for its Zoning Code & Map Update, and it runs through Dec. 1, 2026. Trustees meet at the Carlson Community Center, 50 West Lake Road. The work session is at 6 p.m. and the meeting at 7 p.m., with the next one on Dec. 8 and then Jan. 12.

Lakeside Park is already changing. Paved trails are in, parking near the Chautauqua Belle has been improved, and the Village awarded a $96,851 kayak-launch contract in September 2026, with installation expected next year. The Post-Journal reported the full park project at about $900,000, including a $675,000 state grant.

Filling in the winter weeks

Some of Mayville's food is seasonal. Music For Your Mouth at 21 South Erie St. is closed for the season and posts pop-up events on its site. Andriaccio's at 4837 West Lake Road lists hours of 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. Tuesday through Thursday and 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Friday and Saturday, and it's closed Sunday and Monday.

The next big food weekend is the 40th Mayville Winterfest. The OBSERVER reported it's expected over Presidents' Day weekend in 2027. The 2026 festival ran Friday through Sunday, with food trucks all weekend and a beer-and-wine tent. For more on how Mayville's calendar changes once the summer markets close, see our post on where Thursday night goes after the markets close, along with our Mayville neighborhood guide.

Our office is in Mayville, and we'll be keeping an eye on 188 S. Erie St. along with everyone else. If you own a home near the South Erie Street block or along West Lake Road and wonder how a street with its restaurants back affects your home's value, The Nielsen Wroda Team can start you with an instant home valuation and follow it up with a conversation that's specific to Mayville.

Work With Us

Working with the Nielsen Wroda Team is working with a respected team but also two people who love what they do and bring a sense of fun and joy to the process.

Follow Me on Instagram